29. ABHIDHAMMATTHASANGAHA

Final talk in the series of 16 classes on the Citta Chapter
given at The London Buddhist Vihara during the summer of 1983

According to the Buddhist Teaching there are three kinds of world,' loka' in the Pali language,. Kamaloka, Rupaloka and Arupaloka, three kinds of planes of existence. Kamaloka is called the plane, or we may say sphere, of sense pleasures, this world - according to Buddhism, the world of sense desires. Kama, desire, plays the greatest part in this world, desire through the eye, desire through the ear, nose, tongue, body, mind; desire, meaning greed, is predominant in this world, therefore the name Kamaloka. We can realize in our actions that thing which we have most in everyday life: wish - 'I wish this', 'I wish that'; wish, the desire to have. As consciousness, 'citta' in Pali, it is consciousness of, belonging to, the Plane of Sense Desire; that is, this world.

In this world, Kamaloka, there are altogether for ordinary puthujjanas fifty-four types of consciousness (except one,hasituppada, the smile of the arahatta). We experience some of these fifty-four types, which you have already studied; first of all the akusala states, the eight bad types of immoral, greedy conscious ness; the two hateful, angry types of consciousness; the two ignorant types of consciousness rooted in dullness and delusion - lobha, dosa, moha, altogether twelve. We all of us experience these twelve, I can say every day, every hour if not every time.

Now, resultant types of consciousness, which arise as a result of our immoral actions also the result of our moral actions; they are known as rootless, ahetuka, and are eighteen in number. Looking at the chart we see resultant, 'vipaka' in Pali; bad resultant seven types, good resultant of lower kind eight types, and three inoperative. Thus in all, so far, thirty types: twelve immoral plus eighteen rootless resultant.

Then in this world we also have good types of consciousness known as sobhana, beautiful types of consciousness. There are eight active moral (kusala) types known as beautiful, sobhana, which we experience also more or less every day. Good, moral consciousness means we can do good actions with one of these eight types; anything we do good, we do with one of these types of consciousness. As a result, therefore, we have eight types of good resultant (vipaka) consciousness because of our actions, physical, verbal or vocal, and mental. Because of our beautiful thoughts we utter beautiful words and we do beautiful actions, known as moral actions, as the result of which we have, mentally, eight types of beautiful resultant consciousness. Verbally, as a result of good thoughts (mental action), what we say will be very good, useful, helpful, pleasant; people will like us, love us, appreciate what we say. As a result we shall have everything good, verbally. These types of consciousness can also be experienced by the arahattas, perfect beings like the Buddha and paccekabuddhas, but their actions are not cumulative, their consciousness does not accumulate, does not produce any result, therefore they are only inoperative, 'kiriya' in Pali. Thus, with eight inoperative types of sobhana consciousness, there are in all twenty-four sobhana states making a total of fifty-four types of consciousness that can be experienced in this world, or plane, Kamaloka.

Now we can go higher by developing our good consciousness into higher types of consciousness. For the attainment of the next, higher, plane of consciousness, Rupaloka, the Plane of Form, beings have very fine, refined bodies in that existence, they are all jhanic persons, very highly developed mentally, so high that they can live even thousands of lives, in some cases millions of lives, without eating. Wherever they want to go they can fly without having or bothering to buy tickets, making arrangements, without looking after cars or aeroplanes, in that Rupaloka. Because their physical body is so refined, beautiful; that is one way of explanation of the name Rupa for that existence. Another explanation is that to reach that state, to be born in that world, one's object of meditation is form, not the mind; that is why it is called Rupaloka, the Plane of Form, and the conscious states are known as consciousness of the Plane of Form. In that world their moral actions are five: first, second, third, fourth and fifth jhana, good (kusala) consciousness. They have as a result five resultant, vipaka, types of consciousness. And there are five inoperative, kiriya, types for the Buddhas, also arahattas; in all, therefore, fifteen. In this world fifty-four types of consciousness, and in the Plane of Form fifteen.

Now one can go still higher, Arupaloka, the Formless Plane, where they have no form - as already explained in an earlier class. In that existence there are four moral (kusala) actions, four resultants (vipaka) and four inoperative (kiriya) states, altogether twelve. So in these three planes of existence there are altogether eighty-one types of consciousness known as mundane types of consciousness: in Kamaloka fifty-four. Rupaloka fifteen and in the Formless Plane twelve. Though the Rupa and Arupa types of consciousness are much higher than this world, yet they are still mundane, not supramundane. By attaining these highest types of mundane consciousness we can enjoy life, the great lengths and periods of which are explained in this book (Abhidhammatthasangaha), but still they are only mundane.

When we should like to attain even higher, that highest type of consciousness is called supramundane, Lokuttara. There are four kusala types of Lokuttara consciousness and four types of resultant, making a total of eight types of supramundane consciousness. Thus, including every type of consciousness, eighty-one plus eight, there are in all eighty-nine types of citta.

To study supramundane consciousness please refer to the book, page no. 61, Moral Supramundane Consciousness'. ('A Manual of Abhidhamma' by Narada Mahathera, Buddhist Publication Society, Kandy, Sri Lanka, 1980) There are four types of consciousness, Path consciousness: sotapatti Path consciousness, sakadagami Path consciousness, anagami Path consciousness, arahatta Path consciousness. In Pali they are called sotapattimagga, sakadagamimagga, and so on; magga is translated in English as path. So, altogether four types of Path consciousness; these are the four kusala or moral types of supramundane consciousness. There are exactly the same number of resultant types of supramundane consciousness, 'phala' in Pali, in English, fruit; sotapatti fruit consciousness, sakadagami fruit consciousness, anagami fruit consciousness, arahatta fruit consciousness. Now, reading from the book, 'These are the four types of supramundane moral and resultant consciousness. Thus end, in all, the eight types of supramundane moral and resultant consciousness. Differing according to the four paths the moral consciousness is fourfold. So are the resultants, being their fruits. The supramundane should be understood as eightfold'. And, still following the book, 'Thus the "immorals" are twelve, the "morals" are twenty-one, the "resultants are thirty-six, the "functionals (inoperative)" are twenty. In the Sensuous Sphere, they say, the wise say, 'are fifty-four types of consciousness; in the Form Sphere are fifteen; in the Formless Sphere are twelve; in the Supramundane are eight'.

Next, the explanation of how, why, eighty-nine types of consciousness become one hundred and twenty-one, see page 63 in the book: 'How does consciousness which is analyzed into eighty-nine become one hundred and twenty-one?' You already know eighty-one types of mundane consciousness, and now the eight supramundane are further divided into forty, eighty-one and forty totalling one hundred and twenty-one. The eight supramundane become forty in the following way, as shown in the book, 'The first jhana sotapatti Path consciousness together with initial application, sustained application, joy, happiness and one-pointedness'; you have already studied these jhanic states in Rupaloka, the Plane of Form. 'Second jhana sotapatti Path consciousness together with sustained application, joy, happiness and one-pointedness', and so on, third jhana, fourth, fifth, altogether five. Thus there are five types of sotapatti Path consciousness because of these five jhanas. as is also the case with sakadagami, anagami and arahatta Path consciousness; each is developed into five by way of the five jhanas, making exactly twenty types of Path consciousness. Similarly there are twenty classes of Fruit (phala) consciousness, making in all a total of forty types of supramundane consciousness.

Referring to the summary in the book on page 64: 'Dividing each (supramundane) consciousness into five kinds according to different jhana factors, the supramundane consciousness, it is said, becomes forty. As the Form Sphere consciousness is treated as first jhana consciousness, and so on, even so is the supramundane consciousness. The Formless Sphere consciousness is included in the fifth jhana'.

Here again some explanation is needed. In the Sphere of Form there are three first jhanas - one kusala, one resultant and one inoperative. In Lokuttara there are eight first jhanas - one each in the four Paths and one each in the four Fruits. Thus there are in total eleven first jhanas. Similarly there are eleven second jhanas, third jhanas and fourth jhanas. When, however, it comes to the fifth jhana, not only are there eleven in the way just described, but because all the twelve types of consciousness in the Formless Sphere are of the category of fifth jhana this brings the total of fifth jhana states to twenty-three. Fifth jhana has only two dominant factors, equanimity and one-pointedness of mind. Because all the twelve arupa types of consciousness have only those two dominant factors, they are included in that category.

Referring to the book again, 'Thirty-seven are morals, fifty-two are resultants; thus the wise say that there are one hundred and twenty-one types of consciousness'. Kiriya, the inoperative states, are not mentioned here. 'Thus ends the first chapter of the Abhidhammatthasangaha which deals with the analysis of consciousness'.

Now to show how this supramundane consciousness can be experienced, how only with supramundane consciousness can one attain Nibbana, and not with any of the mundane states. Nibbana is the highest type of happiness and is attained only by the highest types of consciousness. Lokuttara states, not ordinary states of consciousness, therefore ordinary puthujjanas cannot know what Nibbana is, will not understand what it is. If one wants to talk about it one can, but one will not realize it. one cannot appreciate it; by mere thinking, no matter how high one's thoughts are, as long as they are mundane one will never realize Nibbana.

He who practises meditation is called a yogi, and the yogi who wishes to realize Nibbana tries to understand things as they truly are; one must understand what things are. From the book. page 65: 'With his one-pointed mind he scrutinizes his self' - scrutinizes, examines thoroughly, deeply his self; that is, the so-called 'I'. What is self? What is 'I'? If one wants to attain Nibbana one should first examine what 'I' is, what we are; so- 'he scrutinizes his self, and on due examination discovers that his so-called ego, or ego-personality' - the so-called soul - 'is nothing but a mere composition of mind and matter'. If you analyse your body. including the so-called 'I', you or soul, or spirit or , you will discover that the so-called ego-personality, the so-called 'I'. is nothing but a mere composition of mind and matter. 'The former', that is mind, 'consisting of fleeting mental states' - that have already been explained, that you have studied - 'that arise as a result of senses coming into contact with sense stimuli - i.e., an object - 'and the latter' - i.e., matter, body, the composition - 'of forces and qualities that manifest themselves in multifarious phenomena' - many and various kinds of phenomena. So by analysing mind and body one discovers these forces, four kinds of elements, and qualities. These forces are only qualities.

'Having thus gained a correct view of the real nature of his self ' - having analysed the so-called body and mind, and gaining a correct view of the real nature of his self, the so-called 'I' - 'freed from the false notion of an identical substance of mind and matter' - one sees what mind is, what matter is - 'he attempts to investigate the cause of this ego-personality' - this so-called self, or soul, or spirit. 'He realizes that everything worldly, himself not excluded, is conditioned by causes past or present, and that this existence is due to past ignorance (avijja)' - as we said in Paticcasamuppuda, this existence, our own existence, is due to past ignorance - 'craving (tanha), attachment (upadana), kamma' - that is, our action - 'and physical food (ahara) of the present life' - because of food we exist. 'On account of these five causes this personality' - this soul, so-called 'I' - 'has arisen and as the past activities have conditioned the present, so the present will condition the future. Meditating thus', - that is what we call meditation, studying what the so-called 'I', you, is composed of. So, meditation; what is meditation?

Some people use the word contemplation. What is the difference between meditation and thinking, between meditation and contemplation? For the attainment of Nibbana the Pali word is vipassana, and it is translated into English as meditation, which is not an actual equivalent; for the want of words we use the term meditation. Meditation is not the real complete meaning, it does not convey the full meaning of the Pali term vipassana. Vipassana means 'vi' and 'passana'. 'Vi' has two meanings, visesana and vividha. Visesana means specially; passana means seeing; so, to see the object specially, not in an ordinary way is the meaning of visesana. That is to say, when one tries to meditate, when one uses or practises vipassana, one sees objects differently, specially, not in an ordinary way. Ordinarily, when one is not trying to meditate, if one sees a man one is conscious of, aware, there is a man, a woman, there is a dog, cat, and so on, that is the ordinary way of seeing. In a meditative way, in the vipassana way, one does not see a man or woman, one sees specially, one sees that the so-called man and woman are just a composition of mind and matter. One should go beyond the surface, beyond the appearance, that is what we call vipassana, seeing in a special and not ordinary conventional way. One will never realize truth if one sees things in an ordinary conventional way.

Now, vividha, the other meaning of 'vi', means differently, in the light of the Three Characteristics. As a meditator one sees not the body, not the appearance, one sees the so-called object in the light of the Three Characteristics; that is what we call vipassana. This so-called body and mind is subject to change; changing, changing, like the second hand of a clock or watch, changing, following, flowing. So when one sees an object one sees it in the light. of transiency, impermanence; and anything that is changeable is not really desirable. That is dukkha. Then another, the third Characteristic, is, there is no permanent, eternal substance in anything in the world we see, that is to say in animate beings like human beings, animals, there is no eternal principle in a body, no immortal soul. When we say a body, that body is moving, changing; mind and body are moving, and so on. So when as a meditator we see the object specially, not in an ordinary, conventional way, we see it in the light of the Three Characteristics. That is meditation, that is vipassana.

If one refers to the dictionary, meditation means thinking, thinking about, therefore it is entirely different from the meaning of the word vipassana. If one wants to practise Buddhist meditation it means vipassana meditation, to see objects specially, not in the ordinary way, to see objects in the light of the Three Characteristics (anicca, dukkha, anatta).

Now, the book, still on page 65 - 'Meditating thus he transcends all doubts with regard to the past, present and future (kankhavitaranavisuddhi). Thereupon he contemplates that all conditioned things are transient (anicca), subject to suffering (dukkha), and devoid of an immortal soul (anatta). Wherever he turns his eyes he sees nought but these Three Characteristics standing out in bold relief'. He sees them very clearly. 'He realizes that life is a mere flowing, continuous undivided movement. Neither in a celestial plane nor on earth' - earth does not mean the ground, but this world. So, neither in a celestial or divine world. i.e., heaven - 'does he find any genuine happiness, for every form of pleasure is only a prelude to pain'. If one sees this, one sees things as they are, suffering. To ordinary worldly people everything pleasant is supposed to be very pleasurable, enjoyable, but to that person such pleasure is only a prelude to pain. 'What is transient' - impermanent - 'is therefore subject to suffering, and where change and sorrow prevail there cannot be a permanent ego - cannot be a permanent soul.

'As he is thus absorbed in meditation', - vipassana - 'a day comes when, to his surprise, he witnesses an aura emanating' - coming forth - 'from his body (obhasa)'. If his meditation is enhanced he sees an aura, he experiences an unprecedented pleasure, happiness and quietude - 'He becomes even-minded. strenuous. His religious fervour increases' - that is, his strength - 'and mindfulness becomes perfect, and insight extraordinarily keen.

'Mistaking this advanced state of moral progress for sainthood', - the meditator may think, 'Ah! I have attained sainthood, sotapatti' - 'chiefly owing to the presence of the aura, he develops a liking for this mental state. Soon the realization comes that these new developments are only obstacles', - the hindrances - 'to moral progress', they are not real' - 'and he cultivates the purity of knowledge with regard to the Path and non-Path (maggamagganana-dassanavisuddhi)'. So he tries to see whether the path he is following is the real Path or not.

'Perceiving the right path', - so he chooses - 'he resumes his meditation on the arising (udaya nana) and passing away (vayanana) of conditioned things. Of these two characteristics the latter becomes more impressed in his mind, because change is more conspicuous than becoming'. This also needs explanation. This is one of the stages of the nanas when one is meditating on the arising and falling away of one's consciousness, gradually one sees more clearly the falling part than the arising part; that is what it means - 'more impressed in his mind, because change is more conspicuous than becoming. Therefore he turns his attention to the dissolution of things (bhanga nana). He perceives that both mind and matter which constitute his personality, are in a state of constant flux', - change -'not remaining for two consecutive moments the same. To him comes the knowledge that all dissolving things are fearful (bhaya nana). The whole world appears to him like a pit of burning embers, a source of danger. Subsequently he reflects on the wretchedness and vanity (adinava nana) of the fearful world', - to him the world is to be feared - 'and feeling disgusted with it (nibbida nana), wishes to escape therefrom (muncitukamyata nana).

'With this object in view he meditates again on the Three Characteristics (patsankha nana), and thereafter becomes completely indifferent to all conditioned things', - he is not interested in worldly things - 'having neither attachment nor aversion for any worldly object (sankharupekkha nana). Reaching this point of mental culture he takes for his object of special endeavour one of the Three Characteristics that appeals to him most, and intently keeps on developing insight in that particular direction, until that glorious day when, for the first time, he realizes Nibbana, his ultimate goal'.

Now, continuing on page 67 in the book, there is a kind of diagram showing how the process of consciousness takes place. Then - 'When there is no parikamma thought-moment, in the case of an individual with keen insight, there arise three phala thought- moments'. Just the process of consciousness.

'These nine kinds of insight', - namely, udaya-vaya nana, and so on - 'are collectively called patipadananadassanavisuddhi, purity of knowledge and vision as regards the practice.

'Insight found in this supramundane Path consciousness is known as nanadassanavisuddhi, purity of knowledge and vision.

'When the spiritual pilgrim realizes Nibbana for the first time he is called a sotapanna, one who has entered the stream that leads to Nibbana for the first time. He is no more a worldling (puthujjana) but an ariya' -noble one. 'He eliminates three fetters, namely, self-illusion (sakkayaditthi), doubts (vicikiccha), and adherence to wrongful rites and ceremonies'- rituals- '(silabbataparamasa). As he has not eradicated all the fetters that bind him to existence, he is reborn seven times at most' - in this world. 'In his subsequent birth he may or may not be aware of the fact that he is a sotapanna', - first noble one - 'nevertheless, he possesses the characteristics peculiar to such a saint.

'He gains implicit confidence in the Buddha, Dhamma, Sangha', - then he becomes a real Buddhist, really, otherwise one's confidence is very shaky. When one reaches the state of sotapanna, the fiat, initiative state of ariya, one's confidence in the Buddha, Dhamma, is fixed, established - 'and he would never violate any of the five precepts. He is, moreover, absolved from states of woe, for he is destined to enlightenment.

'Summoning up fresh courage as a result of this distant glimpse of Nibbana, the ariyan pilgrim makes rapid progress, and perfecting his insight becomes sakadagami (once returner), by attenuating two other fetters, namely, sense-desire (kamaraga) and illwill (patigha).

'In this case, too, and in the case of the other two advanced stages of sainthood, a javana thought-process runs as above ...'.

Now, just to conclude easily, please read to the end of this section and turn to the last paragraph on page 69.

'It will be noted that the fetters have to be eradicated in four stages'. This comes in the section just mentioned for you to read for yourselves. 'The Path (magga) thought-moment occurs only once. The Fruit (phala) thought-moment immediately follows. In the supramundane classes of consciousness the effect of the kusala cittas is instantaneous. Hence it is called akalika (of immediate fruit); ...'

So in the case of supramundane consciousness, moral (kusala) consciousness, one experiences the result immediately, not like ordinary worldly moral actions, lokiya, mundane states, where 'effects may take place in this life, or in a subsequent life, or at any time until one attains Parinibbana.

'In mundane consciousness kamma is predominant, while in supramundane consciousness panna, or wisdom, is predominant. Hence the four lokuttara cittas are not treated as kamma'. Kamma is only a worldly function. In the case of supramundane moral consciousness, this moral action is not known as kamma because it will not produce an ordinary worldly result; that is the attainment of Nibbana.

"These eight cittas', - types of consciousness - 'are called Lokuttara. Here loka means the pancupadanakkhandha, the five aggregates of attachment. Uttara means that which transcends. Lokuttara therefore means that which transcends the world of aggregates of attachment. This definition strictly applies to the four Paths. The Fruits are called Lokuttara because they have transcended the world of aggregates of attachment'. Lokuttara is really the name for Path consciousness, because the Path is really the work which cuts, or transcends the world. The Fruit is only the result, that is what it means.

Now the rest of this first chapter in the book explains how the eight types of supramundane consciousness become forty. That is the end of the section on citta, consciousness.

Just to conclude our study, our talk, I would like to read, not much, just a little about Nibbana. The book explains how to reach the state of Nibbana; what I am going to read is, what is Nibbana?

Nibbana is the result of the cessation of selfish desires. That is the literal meaning. 'ni' and 'vana'; 'ni' means not, and 'vana' means selfish desire. It may also be defined as extinction of lust, hatred and ignorance, freedom from lust, hatred and ignorance. So Nibbana means the cessation of selfish desire, the absence of craving, hatred and ignorance.

The Pali word is Nibbana, formed, as just said, from the negative particle 'ni' and 'vana'. The Sanskrit word Nirvana comes from the root 'va', which means to blow, and the prefix 'nir' which means off or out; hence Nirvana in its Sanskrit form means the blowing out of the flame of personal desires.

Both explanations are negative explanations of Nibbana. The predominance of the negative explanation of Nibbana resulted in the mistaken notion that it is nothingness; some people even translate Nibbana as nothingness, or annihilation. Annihilation of what, though? They will not say what, but just that Nibbana means annihilation or nothing. If that is so, why should the Buddha have wasted his time for attaining nothing?

However, in the Buddhist scriptures we find many positive definitions of Nibbana, such as: Nibbana means the highest refuge; safety; unique; absolute purity; supramundane; security; emancipation; peace; and so on, there are many positive definitions. Nibbana is, therefore, not a negative concept; because it is the cessation of craving, the blowing out of man's selfish desires, and that blowing out of desires leaves a man free. Nibbana is, therefore, freedom. Freedom, though, does not mean freedom from circumstances, nobody is free from circumstances. It is freedom from the bonds with which we have bound ourselves to circumstances, my circumstance, my activities, my, my; so we bind ourselves to our circumstances, make circumstances as our own. Thus Nibbana is freedom from those bonds.

That man is free if he is free from selfish desire, hatred, illwill, ignorance. That man is free who is strong enough to say, 'Whatever comes I accept as best'. Who can say that? Though we may express it, some people may say it, but actually only the man who is free from these evil fetters can truly say so, only he is really free.

Freedom does not mean that one can do everything that can be imagined; people may think freedom means that one can do anything one likes. Freedom does not mean that one can defeat a lion with a slap of the hand. Some people might think that if one had that kind of power that that would be freedom. Freedom to do anything we wish is not freedom, because still there is a wish, which is a return to the bondage of our desires. Freedom means that one cannot be made a slave to anyone or anything. One is free because one is free from personal desire, free from resentment, free from anger, free from pride, free from fear, impatience; free, from all craving. Such a man's binding emotions have been blown out like so many candles; that man is free here on earth, he has reached Nibbana in this world.

May all be well, healthy, happy, wealthy - you may like to be wealthy - and successful in all your noble undertakings. May you attain this state of Nibbana without much difficulty, and as soon as possible.

30. PATICCASAMUPPADA

A talk given at The London Buddhist Vihara on 9th October 1983

The subject of my talk this evening, as the chart in evidence on the blackboard shows, is Paticcasamuppada.

Paticcasamuppada is a Pali term meaning the Law of Dependent Origination, or Dependent Arising, the arising of a state dependent on the antecedent state. The discourse in Pali on Paticcasamuppada is one of the very well known and very important discourses, because without this aspect of the Teaching it is rather difficult to understand why and how one becomes a being. a human being. This Law of Dependent Origination mainly answers three great questions which had always puzzled the Bodhisatta, the Buddha to be, before he became the Buddha. As the Bodhisatta he had for countless lives practised all kinds of austerities, searching for truth, approaching many well known philosophers and meditation masters, from all of whom he had received all kinds of answers.

Of these three great questions the first is, 'Where did we come from?' Sitting here this evening you may say, '1 came from my home, from my flat' and so on, but this question is not asking an ordinary question; 'Where did we come from into this world, into this existence?' is the question being asked. Do you think you may be able to answer it? For immeasurable lives the Bodhisatta had looked for the answer, but none of the philosophers in any of those periods whom he approached was ever able to give him a satisfactory reply to this question, some saying that if you want to know where you have come from you should know the beginning of life.

There are sixty-two views, wrong views, about existence, where beings come from, how they start; however, if I deal with the sixty- two views you will be remaining here in this vihara all night, so I will take only three views which the Bodhisatta received from those well known philosophers, religious teachers.

The first view given was that the beginning of life is your fate, you must have faith in fate; you cannot do anything by yourself, you have to rely on your fate. Thus they taught that fatalism is the beginning; whatever comes to you it is because of your fate, and you cannot do anything about it. That in Pali is known as sahetuka, the cause of your existence; consequently you cannot make any plan for your own development to be free from all suffering.

And what is suffering? You already know, I think, the very well known Dhammacakkapavattana Sutta, the first sermon preached by the Buddha in which he expounds the Four Noble Truths - Suffering, the Cause of Suffering, the Cessation of Suffering and the Way Leading to the Cessation of Suffering. In Paticcasamuppada suffering is also explained, where it is shown that suffering is together with jati, the Pali word for birth. Birth is suffering. Consider your own birth, how difficult it was, what a dreadful state in a mother's womb as a foetus; to begin with a tiny spot, so tiny that no magnifying glass would help to identify it, then gradually developing, in some cases for seven months, in some for eight, nine months, in a mother's womb; that is suffering. If you were to live in a house say twenty feet wide by twenty feet long, you may say. 'Oh! what a very narrow house, very narrow'. It would not be very comfortable and you would not be regarded as a very rich person if you had to live within such confined conditions, yet consider the room you occupied when as a foetus in a mother's womb. And the suffering of birth is followed by jara, byadhi, old age and decay, death, sorrow, lamentation, physical pain, grief and despair; and a little more than that - to be separated from beloved ones is suffering, to be associated with those whom we dislike is suffering, not to get what one wishes is suffering, and so on; such is dukkha.

Unless one knows this Paticcasamuppada one cannot begin to understand the real nature and function of cause and effect, the cause of suffering, how suffering arises. And in meditation there is a stage where one becomes free from doubt about one's own existence; this again means a knowledge of Paticcasamuppada, a proper understanding of cause and effect, so that no doubts exist as to how one arises and passes away as a human being.

But getting back now to the Bodhisatta's quest for an answer to, 'Where did we come from?' As has already been said, the first view given by one of the well known philosophers was that the beginning of life is due to fate.

The second answer he received was that life started, or has started, without any cause, it just happens, there is no cause.

The third view was that the beginning of life is neither really fatalism nor causeless, the beginning of life is due to a creator, a supreme being, he started it.

So, with the third view that the beginning of life is due to the creation of a supreme being, supreme god, he received those three different answers from the well known philosophers of those times, but the Bodhisatta was not satisfied with any of them. If a supreme being is the cause, he also must have a cause. Without a cause how could he live, who gave him his power of creation, the power to create? The unlimited power of which a supreme god is supposed to be possessed; where did that power come from. originate, how did he start, was there not a prior almighty being who created him, and so on? If you say. 'Oh well, it is normal, it is just natural', then you may say of yourself too, 'I come to this world naturally'; but it still does not answer the question of what cause, what preceding condition gives rise to such a natural, normal happening.

It was not until the Bodhisatta realized this doctrine of Paticcasamuppada, the wheel of life, the continuous process of cause and effect, that he was able to find the answers to his three main questions. On the chart on the blackboard we can see there a big circle depicting the wheel of life. Of the twelve sections, links in the chain, the wheel, can we say which is the beginning, which is the end? The explanation will come.

The Bodhisatta's second question was, 'Why are we here?' Why are we here in this world as human beings, why? We do not know, any more than we know where we came from; ordinary students, ordinary beings do not know the answer.

And the third great question was, 'Where are we going?'

Now, the answer very briefly to the first question, 'Where did we come from?' We come from out of the past, even as today comes out of yesterday. This life is the result of the past life, before this life. We come from out of the things we have done before, out of the past labours unfinished. Although we have laboured, our work is not complete, if it were we should not be here, we should be somewhere higher. We come out of past vices and virtues, vices and virtues we have accumulated, out of the darkness of our own ignorance, out of our own desires. We should like, we desire, to live here; and we should like to come again, we have a great desire to come, but in a better way, physically, mentally, emotionally, morally - any way a little better, if not too much. In the way of wealth we should like, we desire, to be richer, physically more beautiful, to live longer, and so on. Thus we have come down into the present, bringing with us an unlimited accumulation of vices and virtues; therefore we can do evil things, but also we can do wonderful things, good things. In Paticcasamuppada it explains how the process works.

But proceeding now to the second question, 'Why are we here?' We are here because of the past, for the past gives birth to the present, and from the present is born the future. We are brought here by our own joys, our own sorrows, but most of all we are led here by our desires, and here we remain. For how long? Until the last selfish desire is annihilated. Desire for self: 'I want', 'I have a desire to do this and that', countless desires. All elfish desire must be totally annihilated, if there is one left we shall not attain Nibbana yet. To the wise man the life he lives here is an opportunity to rid himself of the burden which he has accumulated in the past; to rid himself of his own wrong doings, his wrong view points, to rid himself of his wrong concepts of life and death, and, leaving them all behind, to place his feet upon the Middle Way. Until then we shall be here, coming back again and again.

And the answer to the third question, 'Where are we going?' We are going to the effects of our causation, the results of our actions, the effects of our causes. Those whose labours are unfinished will go around the wheel of life, known in Pali as samsara. Samsara means going round the wheel of life, returning again and again.

So those whose labours are unfinished merely go around the wheel of life, samsara, and return again to labour towards fuller completion. Those who have followed the Middle Way, the Eightfold Path, and finished their labours, reach the state of Nibbana, complete cessation of all suffering.

Until the Bodhisatta, just before he became the Buddha, realized Paticcasamuppada fully, he was continuously searching for the answers to the above mentioned three great questions which had always puzzled him.

Now, the wheel of life, how do we start? If we refer to the chart we can see there avijja, ignorance. This life begins with - not very pleasant - ignorance, that is how we start, because of ignorance; if we had attained wisdom we should not be here. But in taking avijja as the starting point in the circle, the wheel, the question arises as to what is the cause of avijja? The answer will come later. The wheel does not show the supreme ultimate beginning, the commencement of samsara, it shows the present life, the life we are living now and its relation to the past and future.

So we are starting at avijja, ignorance, in the circle. Ignorance of what? Ignorance, mainly, of the Four Noble Truths; also ignorance of Paticcasamuppada, ignorance of one's own past and present. If we really realize the Four Noble Truths we shall attain wisdom, we shall attain Nibbana, but this circle. Paticcasamuppada, only deals with mundane states because we are as yet mundane beings, it does not deal with supramundane states in which Nibbana is the object of consciousness. So it shows the wheel of life of puthujjanas, ordinary beings. Puthujjana, very thick- skinned, thick with greed, hatred and ignorance; therefore we ordinary people are called puthujjana. that is one of the etymological explanations of puthujjana. So Paticcasamuppada refers only to puthujjana beings, and as such we are going round and round in the whirlpool of this circle without finding the outlet.

In order to discover the outlet our job is to know the Four Noble Truths. The Truth of Suffering, as briefly discussed earlier, everyone experiences from the beginning in a mother's womb. The Truth of the Cause of Suffering: the cause is craving, craving for existence, greed for this and that. The Truth of the Cessation of Suffering, release from suffering: that is Nibbana, The Truth of the Way Leading to the Cessation of Suffering: that is the Eightfold Path. If one knows the Four Truths really, not theoretically but with full realization, one can get out of this circle.

Next to avijja in the circle comes sankhara. Sankhara is translated in different ways - literally it means doing, acting; it means activities, mainly mental activities. Abhidhamma students who are present here will know the twenty-nine possible types of active conscious states that may take place in the case of puthujjanas, the twelve immoral states, eight moral and nine meditational states. Sankhara, here, means these twenty-nine types of consciousness. Owing to ignorance sometimes we do good actions, but mostly we do bad actions because mostly we do things rooted in greed and hatred. Under the influence of ignorance we do all kinds of actions. We are ignorant really of which is right and wrong, although we may know just generally that certain actions might be good, certain actions might not be good. Therefore, blinded by ignorance we do wrong actions, although sometimes we do good actions, but not commonly. Generally we do actions because we like, which means based on greed; in the main greed is our guide, desire is our guide, we are guided by greed. So we like this and that and the other all the time, all the time wanting, wishing. And why? Because of avijja, not understanding the result of greed, without knowing the influence or power of greed. If we do not get what we want we are disappointed, frustrated, we get angry and wild; but the result of this is not mentioned yet, here.

There are altogether twelve factors in this circle, Paticcasamuppada, and there are three periods. i.e., past, present and future. As the starting point we have mentioned avijja, the first factor, ignorance of the Four Noble Truths, and so on. Hoping to get a good result we do actions; that is sankhara, the second factor. These two factors, avijja and sankhara, are the past period, and they have brought us to this world. Our past good actions such as giving, offering dana, observing certain precepts, having some good thoughts; because of good kamma in the past we come to this world.

So, because of sankhara the third factor arises, vinnana, rebirth consciousness in this world. Vinnana is the present period, resultant section, arising as the result, the outcome of the past avijja-sankhara, the cause. Vinnana, here, means not all types of consciousness but rebirth consciousness after death. Thus, beginning this present life, we have first patisandhi consciousness - relinking consciousness - that which links this present life with the past. Rebirth consciousness arises, we are reborn, that is why we use the word rebirth, not reincarnation which means a soul is reborn. In Buddhism, because there is no soul, we do not use the word reincarnation or incarnation.

Consciousness cannot work alone, it has some associated mental factors which work together with it, in Pali known as cetasikas; and being mind it cannot exist alone, it needs a body as a result of past actions. Therefore because of our relinking consciousness, dependent upon our relinking consciousness, we have mind and body, nama and rupa, the fourth factor in the circle. The translation given on this chart here is mentality for nama and materiality for rupa, but mind and body is rather easier to understand.

Then, because of mind and body, depending on mind and body, you have six bases, the fifth factor in the circle. We have five external sense bases: eye, ear, nose, tongue and body (touch). We also use the Pali word dvara, meaning door, because of two functions. Through the eye-door, for example, we take a visible object. and through the eye-door we let it go; therefore the eye has two functions, coming and going. The term base is used in the sense of a base upon which consciousness can function. And the sixth is an internal base, or inner door, the mind-door. It has two meanings, for it is not only a base or door but it is our life-line as well in Pali, bhavanga - which leads us on from birth to birth. following this wheel round and round. Physically the heart is mentioned as the base for thought. And so, depending on nama and rupa, mind and body, we have six bases. Depending on these six bases, because of them, there is contact, the sixth factor in the circle. Contact - in Pali, phassa - impression, impingement. Contact means there is contact between an external sense object and the appropriate sensory surface, or sense base. For example, when a visible object and the sensitive surface of the eye, the eye base, are at a correct distance and there is proper light, then contact between the two arises, the visible object impinges on the sensitive surface of the eye. Similarly with sounds and ear base. In the Abhidhamma it is fully explained how it works with forms and sight, and so on. Because of the five sense-doors, and mind-door, because of these bases, or doors, we have contact. When something touches the physical body, then contact arises via the body-door (touch); that is phassa, contact.

Now because of contact one feels, feeling arises, the seventh factor in the circle. When there is contact with an object of touch via the body-door, one feels. If the touch is smooth one may have a pleasant feeling, if the touch is rough or coarse one may have an unpleasant feeling, a neutral feeling, and so on. So because of feeling contact arises- in Pali, phassa paccaya vedana.

Looking at the circle on the board we can see that avijja-sankhara are the past period. From vinnana (rebirth consciousness) to vedana (feeling) inclusive, these five are the present period. Because of the past we are born in this life, to begin with. rebirth consciousness; because of which there is mind and body; and because of body there are the six bases; because of the six bases there is contact; and because of contact feeling arises. These five in the present life come as a result of avijja-sankhara, our past actions, and are shown on the chart as the present resultant section.

When pleasant feeling arises, liking arises, 'I like it', greed arises, craving - tanha - the eighth factor in the circle. It is due to feeling that craving arises; without feeling greed cannot arise. When we see something, hear something. if it is pleasant, 'Ah' I like it, I must have it, I cannot do without it', pleasant sights, sounds, and so on, mostly selfish desire or wish for self. Then what about unpleasant feeling? In Paticcasamuppada, when greed arises depending on feeling, how can we have greed for something which we dislike? The answer to this question is given in Visuddhimagga. In the case of unpleasant feeling, say one is ill, sick, one has a very painful ache, still greed arises because we have a desire to get out of that pain, to be free from that unpleasant feeling; so, craving arises either way, following pleasant or unpleasant feeling.

Some people who are poor would like to be rich, this is desire. Some rich people desire to be richer; so, greed by the poor, greed by the rich. The more one gets the more one wants, more greedy really. This greed, this desire in this present life does not belong to the resultant section which ends at vedana, we go on now to the new thing, the new activity, doing. committing. producing that which is the cause of our future. From these activities, as a result of them, so our future will manifest itself. Thus tanha, craving, is new, fresh activity, the commencing factor in this period shown on the chart as the present causal section.

To repeat - because of the past, avijja-sankhara, we have five present resultants: vinnana, nama-rupa, salayatana, phassa and vedana. Nama-rupa, as you know, is counted as one factor. So we are here, enjoying our past, the result of our past action, and now we are going to do new things. If we try to stop going round this wheel, to get out of this circle, we shall have to become without tanha, craving, greed.

Once tanha has arisen then attachment follows, in Pali upadana; that is the ninth factor in the circle. The difference between tanha (craving, greed) and upadana (attachment) - in English it is very clear - tanha is light desire, upadana is deeply rooted, we are attached. Greed is not attached, does not reach the state of attachment, it is just ordinary desire, wish.

Following attachment bhava, becoming, arises; the tenth factor in the circle. Tanha paccaya upadana, upadana paccaya bhava. What does it mean, becoming? Becoming means we are starting. acquiring new, fresh kammic energy for future life. Bhava has two aspects: kamma-bhava, action cumulative of resultant, and upapatti-bhava, resultant tending towards rebirth. In other words, because of our craving and attachment we act, now, do present actions (kamma-bhava), which means we are preparing for future birth, rebirth (upapatti-bhava).

Therefore tanha, upadana and bhava also belong to the present period but not as resultants due to actions in the past, but as present actions causing, giving rise to the future.

As we have said, by way of our present actions, doings. we are preparing for future birth, rebirth, and so we come to the eleventh factor in the circle, jati. Jati means born, arises. When we have finished this life then the next birth will come. What will be born, what will arise? When the next birth comes the five factors shown in the chart here as the present resultant section will, one after another, arise, that is: vinnana, nama-rupa, salayatana. phassa, vedana., but instead of saying these five we use only the one word, jati, born, meaning the beginning of the future life. So the future result means that mind, body, bases, contact and feeling, these five will be born.

Thus jati means the beginning of this life. The twelfth factor in the circle, however, jaramarana, means the end of one's life, jara meaning old age, gradually, and marana, death. As a natural sequence there are some other states such as soka - soka means sorrow, because we have been born we are subject to sorrow - lamentation, pain, grief and despair will arise as a result of birth.

Well, altogether we see here twelve factors. Two, avijja and sankhara, belong to the past; five, from vinnana to feeling, belong to the present as a result of the past; tanha, upadana and bhava belong to the present, causing the future; jati and jaramarana belong to the future, resulting from present causes. From jati to jaramarana, just two things mentioned here, but it means these five here on the chart, the five factors in the present resultant section, from vinnana to vedana. The combination of these five factors are called man and woman, and it is these five which are born, die and are reborn in interminable continuity because of present actions.

Well, the time is up. I usually give three talks on Paticcasamuppada, for to cover all the points in one talk is impossible; what I have said gives only a very brief, most brief outline. To conclude our talk, my talk, I should like to mention the real teaching of the Buddha, the advice of the Buddha to get out of this wheel of life. If we do not follow it we shall go round and round, without a limit

To unmask the great illusion is the labour of man, so the Buddha advised us to get rid of our ignorance, to get rid of our masks of delusion, illusion. To stand in equilibrium in the midst of worldly things is the way of the Buddha. To contemplate life, but never to be enmeshed within worldly life is the law of the Buddha; not to be attached, tangled in the whirlpool of life, worldly life. To go forth out of worldly life into higher and spiritual life is the advice of the Buddha. To be absorbed into the reality, the supreme bliss of Nibbana is the end of the Buddhist way of life.

31. NIBBANA

Nirvana, which is the Sanskrit form of the Pali word Nibbana, is a combination of 'ni' and 'vana', 'ni' being a negative particle, and 'vana' meaning lusting or craving. It is called Nibbana, for it is a departure from that craving; or it may also be defined as the extinction of greed, hatred and ignorance.

'The whole world is in flames', says the Buddha. By what fire is it kindled? It is kindled by the fire of greed, hatred and ignorance, by the fire of birth, old age, death, pain, lamentation, sorrow, grief and despair.

It should not be thought that Nibbana is a state of nothingness or annihilation just because we cannot conceive it with our worldly knowledge; a blind man cannot say that light does not exist just because he is unable to see it. There is the story, too, of the fish who argued with his friend the turtle, asserting triumphantly that there was no such thing as land.

Nibbana of the Buddhists is neither a mere nothingness nor a state of annihilation, but exactly what it is no words can adequately express. It is a dhamma which is uncreated and unformed, hence it is boundless, to be sought after, happy, because it is free from all suffering, free from birth, death and so on. Nibbana is not situated in any place, nor is it a sort of heaven where a transcendental ego resides, it is a state which is dependent upon ourselves.

THE PATH TO NIBBANA

How is Nibbana to be attained? It is by following the Noble Eightfold Path. which consists of morality (sila), concentration (samadhi) and wisdom (panna).

To refrain from all evil,
To do what is good.
To cleanse one's mind,
This is the teaching of all the Buddhas.

DISCIPLINES

Sila, or morality, is the first stage on the path to Nibbana. One should not kill or cause injury to any living creature, one should be kind and compassionate towards all, even the tiniest creature that crawls at one's feet. Refraining from stealing anything, we should be honest in all our dealings. Abstaining from sexual misconduct which debases the exalted nature of man, we should be pure and chaste. Shunning false speech we should be truthful. Avoiding intoxicating drinks which promote heedlessness, we should be sober and diligent.

If the spiritual man finds these five precepts too elementary he may advance a step further and observe the eight or even ten precepts.

It will be noticed that as the spiritual man proceeds on this highway he is expected to live a life of celibacy, simplicity and self-control, lest vigour and well-being might encourage indolence, and worldly bonds might impede his progress. While the spiritual man progresses slowly and steadily it is naturally easy for him to practise the four kinds of higher sila, namely, discipline as prescribed by the Patimokkha, sense restraint, purity of conduct connected with livelihood, and conduct in connection with the necessaries of life.

Having trodden the ground of sila, the progressing spiritual man reaches the practice of samadhi, the culture of the mind, the second stage of this path. Samadhi is concentration of the mind at will on one object.

The third stage on the path to Nibbana is insight (panna) which enables the spiritual man to see things as they truly are. With one pointedness of mind he looks at the world to get a correct view of life, seeing nothing but the three characteristics. anicca (impermanence), dukkha (suffering) and anatta (soullessness), wherever he casts his glance. He does not find any genuine happiness in the world, for he sees that every form of pleasure is only a prelude to pain. Whatever is impermanent is painful, thus where change and sorrow prevail there cannot be permanent happiness.

The advancing spiritual man then takes one of the above three characteristics which appeals to him most, and intently keeps on developing insight in that particular direction until he realizes Nibbana for the first time in his life. Having at this ariyan stage destroyed the first three of the ten fetters, namely, self-illusion (sakkyaditthi), doubts (vicikiccha) and indulgence in rites, rituals and ceremonies, he is called a sotapanna, one who has entered the stream that leads to Nibbana; he has forever escaped the states of woe, and is assured of final enlightenment.

More than any earthly power.
More than all the joys of heaven.
More than rule o'er all the world
Is the entrance to the Stream.

However, since he has not destroyed the will to live, he will be reborn as a human being seven times at most if he does not make quick further attainment.

Being encouraged by the result of this distant glimpse of Nibbana the spiritual man develops deeper insight, and weakening two more fetters, sense desire (kamaraga) and illwill (patigha), he becomes a sakadagami, a once returner. He is called this because he will be reborn on earth only once more if he does not attain arahatship.

When he reaches the third ariyan stage the spiritual man is called an anagami (never returner), at which stage he completely destroys the above two fetters. Hereafter he does not return to this world, for he has no more desire for worldly pleasures, and after death he is reborn in the Pure Abodes (Suddhavasa), a place which is exclusively for anagamis and from whence they will become arahatta.

Now the earnest spiritual man, encouraged by the great success of his endeavours, makes his final advance, and destroying the remaining fetters, namely, desire for life in the Realm of Form (ruparaga), desire for life in the Formless Realm (aruparaga), conceit (mana), distraction (uddhacca) and ignorance (avijja), he becomes a perfected saint by attaining arahatship. In this fourth supramundane stage he is called an arahat, one whose heart becomes free from sensual passion, free from the passion for existence and free from ignorance. He realizes that rebirth is exhausted, the holy life is fulfilled, and what was to be done has been done; this is the highest, holiest peace, the eradication of greed, hatred and ignorance. The arahat stands on heights more than celestial, realizing the unutterable bliss of Nibbana. He no more arises, no more passes away, no more trembles and no more desires; there is nothing in him to cause re-arising. Because he arises no more, he will not grow old; growing old no more he will not die again; dying no more he will not tremble, and trembling no more he will not desire. Hence the purpose of the holy life does not consist in acquiring alms, honour or fame, nor in gaining morality, concentration or wisdom. The unshakable deliverance of the heart is the object of the holy life, this is its essence and its goal.

Top | Contents | 01 | 02 | 03 | 04 | 05