Two: Description of the Metres
2.1 The types of metre
In most metres a verse (gàthà) is made up of 4 lines (pàda), though sometimes we find verses with 6 lines, or more rarely 5. Pàëi metres are constructed according to the amount of syllables or measures there are in the line, and the patterns that are made through the alternation of the light and heavy syllables.
The metres can be divided into two main types according to their method of construction, in outline they are:
1) The syllabic metres (vaõõacchandas)
2) The measure metres (mattàchandas)
We can usefully divide these into two further groups, according to the specific basis for their construction, numbers 1 and 4 below are syllabic metres, further divided according to whether their syllables are flexible or fixed; numbers 2 and 3 are types of measure metres, according to whether they have been further organized into bars or not. We then have four main groups:
1) The flexible syllabic metres, e.g Siloka, Tuññhubha, Jagatã
2) The measure metres (proper), e.g. Vetàlãya, Opacchandasaka, & âpàtalikà
3) The bar metres, e.g. Gãti, Ariyà, Gubbinã
4) The fixed syllabic metres, e.g. Upajàti, Rathoddhatà, Uggatà
In the flexible syllabic metres it is the number of syllables that make up a line that is the organizing principle, e.g. Siloka has 8 syllables to the line, Tuññhubha 11, & Jagatã 12. Variations are allowed in regard to the weight of a numbers of the syllables in these metres (the various patterns that can occur are discussed in the descriptions that follow).
In the measure metres the syllables may vary in amount, but the total amount of measures should remain fixed (
Û = 1 measure, Ü = 2 measures), e.g. Vetàlãya has 14 measures (mattà) in the 1st & 3rd lines, and 16 in the 2nd & 4th; Opacchandasaka 16 in the 1st & 3rd, 18 in the 2nd & 4th; âpàtalikà has the same mattà count as Vetàlãya, but the cadence is different.In the bar metres a secondary organising principle is employed over and above that of counting the measures, which is to organize the syllables into bars, normally of 4 measures to the bar. e.g Ariya has 16 bars, with 30 measures in its 1st line, and 27 in the second; Gãti has 16 bars, with 30 measures in both lines (how these figures are arrived at will be explained below).
In the fixed metres virtually all of the syllables in the lines are of fixed quantity, with normally only the weight of the beginning and end syllables being variable, e.g. Upajàti is a fixed form of the Tuññhubha metre, having 11 syllables to the line; Vaüsaññhà is a fixed form of Jagatã, having 12 syllables to the line.
After this brief outline of the different structural principles involved we can examine the metres in more depth.
2.2 The flexible syllabic metres, vaõõacchandas
(varnacchandas) type 1
(aka akkharacchandas [Skt: akùaracchandas])
In these the line length is determined by the number of syllables there are in a line, e.g. Siloka normally has 8; Tuññhubha 11; Jagatã 12. These metres have a more or less fixed cadence (i.e. the closing rhythm of a line), but allow a greater freedom in the rest of the line, in which they differ from vaõõacchandas type 2. The syllabic metres are the most common type found in the canon.
2.3 Siloka (øloka)
aka Vatta (Vaktra) & Anuññhubha (Anuùñubh)
The most important and prevalent metre in canonical Pàëi is the Siloka, which has a great deal of flexibility, and seems to be equally well adapted to aphorism, question & answer, narrative, and epic.
A Siloka verse normally consists of 4 lines (sometimes 6, rarely 5) with 8 syllables to the line, organised in dissimilar pairs which are repeated to make up a verse (note that owing to resolution sometimes a Siloka line may contain 9 syllables).
Here is an analysis of the pathyà (normal) structure of the Siloka:
Odd (prior) line: Even (posterior) line: |
É Å Å Å Ð Û Ü Ü Å É Å Å Å Ð Û Ü Û Å x 2 |
In the 2nd & 3rd positions two successive light syllables
ÛÛ are normally avoided, as we can see through occasional changes of syllabic weight in words that occur in these positions. However, there appear to be texts (e.g. Dhammapada) in which this rule is not always applied.
2.4 Siloka Variations
The cadence at the end of the even lines
ÛÜÛÅ is very well established and normally adhered to, but occasionally other patterns show up in this position, and we should perhaps take them as acceptable, even if extraordinary, variations, they are: ÜÜÛÅ and ÛÜÜÅ, others are doubtful.In the odd lines 7 variations (vipulà) occur, besides the normal structure, they are:
aka |
|||
javipulà navipulà bhavipulà mavipulà ravipulà savipulà tavipulà |
ÉÅÅÅ Ð ÛÜÛÅ ÉÜÅÜ Ð ÛÛÛÅ ÉÜÅÜ Ð ÜÛÛÅ ÉÜÅÜ Ð ÜÜÜÅ ÉÅÅÅ Ð ÜÛÜÅ ÉÅÅÅ Ð ÛÛÜÅ ÉÜÛÜ Ð ÜÜÛÅ |
Anuññhubha 1st vipulà 2nd vipulà 3rd vipulà 4th vipulà 5th vipulà 6th vipulà (very sporodic) |
There is normally a caesura (word break) after the fifth syllable in the mavipulà, and after the fourth syllable in the ravipulà.
Occasionally other patterns show up in the opening of the na- and bha-vipulàs such as
ÅÛÜÜ, but only rarely. As can be seen in the descriptions above, resolution of the first syllable is quite common and acceptable. The 6th & 4th are occasionally resolved, and apparently the 3rd, 5th, & 7th can be also, but not the 2nd or the 8th. By applying the rule of resolution described in 1.15 above, it is possible to help identify the underlying structure of a vipulà, take the case of an odd line showing the following structure:ÅÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÅ
if the caesura (word break) occurs after the fourth syllable, it is ravipulà:
ÅÜÛÜ
, ÐÛÛÛÜÅif the caesura occurs after the 5th syllable, it is pathyà:
ÅÜÛÜÐÛ
, ÛÛÜÅ
2.5 Siloka periods
The Siloka metre in the canon can be divided roughly into two periods, the early and the late, according to whether the Anuññhubha variation occurs in the prior lines, or whether it is normally avoided. In the early period the pathyà accounts for about 60% or more of the prior lines, and the Anuññhubha at that time is the most important variation accounting for about 15%. As the metre comes closer to its classical form in the later part of the canon the Anuññhubha occurs only sporadically, and the pathyà greatly predominates, sometimes accounting for as much as 85% of all the lines (for more on the development of the Siloka, see the Appendix).
An interesting comparison is afforded between the early Siloka of the questions and answers in Pàràyanavagga of Suttanipàta, and the late Siloka of the Introductory Verses (Vatthugàthà). We may note here that in Hemakamàõavàpucchà (Sn V:8) (vs 1084 ff) we may have a case of the Anuññhubha being used as an independent metre in the canon, but as it is only 4 vs long it is too short to be sure.
Early Siloka from Jatukaõõãmàõavapucchà (Sn V: 12) (vs 1098-99):
ÜÜÛÛÐÛÛÜÜÐÐÜÜÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ savipulà
ÜÛÜÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÜÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ Pathyà
ÜÜÜÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÜÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ Pathyà
ÜÜÜÜÐÛÜÛÜÐÐÛÛÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ Anuññhubha
Late Siloka (Sn V vs 1-3) (vs 976-978), narrative style:
ÜÛÜÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÛÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ Pathyà
ÜÜÜÜÐÜÛÜÜÐÐÜÛÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ ravipulà
ÜÜÛÜÐÛÛÛÜÐÐÛÛÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ navipulà
ÛÜÜÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÜÛÛÐÛÜÛÜ Pathyà
ÜÜÛÛÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÜÛÛÐÛÜÛÜ Pathyà
ÛÜÜÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ Pathyà
2.6 Tuññhubha (Triùñubh), & Jagatã
Tuññhubha in the canon occurs in basically three forms. In the early period Tuññhubha verses are used in the main independently. Only occasionally do we find Jagatã lines in the early verses, and then only as an expedient, as it were.
1 Later in the middle period we find that these two metres are frequently intermixed in composition, and at that point we might better describe the metre as being Tuññhubha-Jagatã. Later still these metres are replaced by their classical counterparts Upajàti and Vaüsaññhà (described in 2.8 below).As the variations that occur in the one also occur in the other, we can take the two metres together for description.
Tuññhubha normally has 11 syllables to the line, and is defined thus:
É
Ü Û Ü Ð Å Û Å Ð Ü Û Ü Å x 4Jagatã is similar, but has an extra light syllable in penultimate position, giving a line of 12 syllables, thus:
É
Ü Û Ü Ð Å Û Å Ð Ü Û Ü Û Å x 4
2.7 Tuññhubha Variations
The normal opening in both metres is described as being
ÅÜÛÜ , but there are a significant number of occasions when variations are seen (especially in the early period), the most common being ÅÜÜÜ, but also we come across ÅÜÛÛ, ÅÛÜÜ & ÜÛÛÜ. Others occur only very rarely.In the break (syllables 5-7) the pattern
ÜÛÛ prevails (85% approx), with resolution occasionally giving ,ÛÛÛÛ. Other patterns that occur in this position are ÛÛÜ, ÜÛÜ, & ÛÛÛ. Rarely we also find the patterns ÜÜÛ and ÛÜÛ, so that the 6th syllable, though normally light, may occasionally be heavy.Sometimes an extended form is produced by resolution at the first syllable, which then gives a line of 12 (13) syllables - note that the pattern of the cadence will help identify the metre in these cases.
Another extended form may be produced by a line having a caesura
at the 5th syllable, and restarting from the same syllable, giving the line:5 & 5
Å
Ü Û Ü Ð Ü, É Û Å Ð Ü Û Ü (Û) ÅOccasionally replacement takes place, whereby two light syllables are presumed in the 6th & 7th positions, and replaced by one heavy one. The line then has one syllable less than expected (see 1: 16 above for an example):
6 & 7
É
Ü Û Ü Ð Ü Ü Ð Ü Û Ü (Û) ÅExamples: early Tuññhubha, Khaggavisàõasutta Sn I:3; the "Aññhaka" suttas Sn IV:2-5; and the Tuññhubha verses in Pàràyanavagga Sn V. The second of the extended forms described above is used extensively in the Vatthugàthà to Nàlakasutta Sn III:11 (vs 679ff). Late Tuññhubha tends to conform to the fixed patterns that emerged during this time and which are described below (for more on the development of the Tuññhubha, see the Appendix).
Example of early Tuññhubha from Guhaññhakasutta (Sn IV: 2) (vs 776-779):
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÜÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÜÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÜÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÛÜÛÜÐÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÜÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÜÛÐÜÛÜÜ
Mixed Tuññhubhajagatã, from Ratanasutta (Khp 6:8):
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ Jagatã
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ Jagatã
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ Tuññhubha
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ Jagatã
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ Tuññhubha
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ Tuññhubha
Extended Tuññhubha, from Nàlakasutta (Sn III: 11) (vs 679-680):
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
sakkacca Indaü sucivasane ca deve,
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÛÛÜÛÛÐÜÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÛÜÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
2.8 Upajàti, Vaüsaññhà (Vaü÷asthà), and Rucirà
These are the fixed metres in the canon that have been derived from Tuññhubha and Jagatã, their profile looks like this:
i) Upajàti (from Tuññhubha):
Å
Ü Û Ü Ð Ü Û Û Ð Ü Û Ü Å x4ii) Vaüsaññhà (from Jagatã):
Å
Ü Û Ü Ð Ü Û Û Ð Ü Û Ü Û Å x4As can be seen these are the "normal" forms of their respective metres, but now allowing only little flexibility.
iii) Rucirà (from Jagatã, with resolution of the 5th syllable, giving a 13 syllable line):
Å
Ü Û Ü Ð Û Û Û Û Ð Ü Û Ü Û Å x4Examples: Upajàti and Vaüsaññhà are used to great effect, both mixed and independently in Tàlaputta's gàthàs Th 1091-1145. Vaüsaññhà and Rucirà both appear as independent metres in Lakkhaõasuttanta DN.30 (see 2.24)
Example Upajàti/Vaüsaññhà, Th 1091-2:
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ Upajàti
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ Upajàti
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ Upajàti
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ Vaüsaññhà
ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ Vaüsaññhà
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ Vaüsaññhà
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ Upajàti
ÜÜÛÜÐÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ Upajàti
Rucirà from Lakkhaõasuttanta (D. 30. 2. 9):
ÛÜÛÜÐÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
ÛÜÛÜÐÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
ÜÜÛÜÐÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
ÛÜÛÜÐÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
End Notes
1 The last two sections of Suttanipàta are considered to contain some of the earliest texts in the canon. And in the first of these books, Aññhakavagga (Sn IV), there are only 4 Jagatã lines among nearly 400 lines of Tuññhubha (there is also one Jagatã verse, no 836). In Pàràyanavagga (Sn V), the Jagatã lines amount to approx 7% of the lines in the Tuññhubha verses.
2 1st syllable is resolved, 4th syllable is short, we might have expected to find a reading isã
3 Perhaps we should understand avÖcƒsi m.c.
4 Showing resolution of the 5th syllable
5 This is an Upajàti line
6 Reading kariya as having 3 syllables